Florida Comparative Negligence Examples After HB 837
Florida’s comparative negligence law can reduce or prevent compensation when an injured person shares blame for an accident. Under Fla. Stat. § 768.81(6), a person who is more than 50% at fault generally can’t recover damages in most negligence cases. At 50% or less fault, the court reduces their compensation by their share of responsibility. HB 837 introduced this change for causes of action filed after March 24, 2023.
If you were injured in an accident and an insurer says you share the blame, reach out to Carman & Finegan. Our personal injury lawyers in Florida can explain how that fault finding could affect your compensation.
A 20% Share of Fault Reduces Compensation by 20%
Imagine a driver in Tampa is injured in a crash and has $120,000 in damages. The other driver caused most of the collision, but evidence shows the injured driver was also 20% at fault. If the final fault finding assigns the injured driver 20% responsibility, their potential recovery falls by $24,000, leaving $96,000. The actual award depends on the evidence and the damages established.
A 50% Share of Fault Still Allows Recovery in Florida
Let’s say a pedestrian crossing a street in St. Petersburg is hit by a delivery driver. The evidence supports a finding that both were equally responsible. If the pedestrian has $100,000 in damages and is found 50% at fault, the potential recovery is $50,000. Florida’s rule bars recovery only when the injured person is more than 50% at fault. An even split doesn’t trigger that bar.
A 51% Share of Fault Can Bar Recovery in a Personal Injury Case
Suppose a diner at a Sarasota restaurant slips on a wet floor. The restaurant may have failed to address the hazard. However, evidence also shows the diner was looking at a phone and didn’t notice the danger. If the evidence supports finding the diner 51% responsible for the injury, they generally can’t recover damages under Florida’s comparative fault rule.
Even with $100,000 in proven damages, the diner would recover nothing under the general rule if found more than 50% at fault. A fall alone doesn’t establish that the restaurant was legally responsible. The evidence must support the claim against the property owner.
Florida Medical Negligence Claims Follow a Different Rule
Unlike most Florida negligence cases, a medical negligence claim isn’t automatically barred when the injured patient is more than 50% at fault. The patient’s share of responsibility can still reduce the damages awarded, but it doesn’t trigger the same cutoff. This exception appears in Fla. Stat. § 768.81(6), which excludes qualifying medical negligence claims under Chapter 766 from the greater-than-50% bar.
For instance, if a patient has $100,000 in damages and is found 70% responsible for the harm, the patient could still recover $30,000 if the healthcare provider is found legally responsible for the injury. So while the exception removes the greater-than-50% bar, it doesn’t eliminate the need to prove medical negligence.
Talk to Our Florida Personal Injury Attorneys About an Unfair Fault Assessment
Whether you were hurt in a car crash, truck wreck, pedestrian crash, slip and fall accident, medical malpractice incident, or another accident, never assume an insurer’s fault assessment is final. Our personal injury lawyers in Florida can review the evidence, challenge an unsupported allocation of blame, and explain how different fault findings could affect your potential compensation. You can discuss your case for free with our Florida personal injury attorneys at Carman & Finegan by calling our office at 813-654-3444 or submitting our contact form.